Marvel Database

What If? Spider-Man The Other Vol 1 1

Redirected from What If? Vol 5 4

151,834pages on
this wiki

What If? Spider-Man The Other Vol 1 1
November 15, 2006
Previous Issue
Next Issue

What If? Avengers Disassembled
What If? Wolverine Enemy of the State

Appearing in "What if Spider-Man had rejected the Spider? Poison Selves"Edit

Featured Characters:

Supporting Characters:


Other Characters:




Synopsis for "What if Spider-Man had rejected the Spider? Poison Selves"Edit

Uatu the Watcher summarizes a series of events in which Peter Parker, suffering from cellular degeneration, was attacked by Morlun, but instead killed Morlun before seemingly perishing himself. Confronted by the manifestation of his spider-essence, the Peter Parker of Earth-616 chose to embrace his inner spider and was reborn with augmented powers. Uatu questions what would happen if that confrontation had occurred differently.

After his death, Peter Parker encounters the manifestation of his spider-powers, but rather than accepting its offer he rips its head off. As it dies, the Spider-Totem berates Peter for his actions, but Peter retorts that he's not entitled to be resurrected since better people than him have died permanently, and that the risks of coming back more spider than man are too great. Peter refuses to be the Spider-Totem's puppet, and states that if that costs him his life then so be it. Peter's choice leaves him stranded in his dream-scape, his comatose body webbed in its cocoon beneath the Brooklyn Bridge.

In prison, Mac Gargan sneers that such a prison may have been able to hold him as the Scorpion but not as Venom, while the guards dryly snark at his rant. Gargan's tirade is interrupted by the Venom symbiote sensing that something has happened to Spider-Man and it immediately abandons him to return to its first true love. Ignoring Gargan's pleas for it to return, the symbiote escapes Gargan's cell, takes over a guard, and slaughters the others before using its new host as a vehicle to get to the Brooklyn Bridge, abandoning him to fall to his death. The symbiote senses that Peter's metamorphosis is stalled and enters into the cocoon intending to complete his transformation. A struggle between the symbote's will and Peter's psyche ensues that lasts for several months, but the symbiote succeeds in gradually breaking Peter down and permanently bonds to his body.

The resulting entity emerges from the cocoon in the middle of a thunderstorm. At Stark's apartment, Mary Jane awakens from a nightmare screaming, and Aunt May tries to calm her down. As they talk, the entity crashes through the window. When Mary Jane calls him Venom, the entity attempts to reassure her. Horrified, Aunt May recognizes Peter's voice, but the entity rebukes her, stating the permanent bond between the symbiote and Peter is an act of true love, a miracle surpassing those prayed for in church. When Mary Jane accuses him of being Venom again, the entity refutes her again, denouncing Venom as a "hopeless loser" and dubbing itself Poison. Poison offers to bond Mary Jane to a symbiote spawn so that they can be together, but Mary Jane snaps that she'd rather be dead. Poison remarks that he could simply resurrect her as a mindless shell controlled by his will, which he quips might actually be preferable. He is interrupted by Wolverine and Luke Cage, but easily defeats them. Mary Jane tells Poison to get out, but he refuses to go without her. To Poison's confusion, Mary Jane abruptly accepts his offer, and she explains that his existence sickens her but she's tired of living on an emotional roller coster and doesn't want others getting hurt protecting her. However, she vows that she will make Poison's life a living hell.

Poison leaves without harming Mary Jane, travelling to the Forest Hills Cemetery, unearthing Gwen Stacy's grave and cocooning her corpse to the side of a wall. As Poison watches, a red-and-black clawed hand rips through the cocoon.

  • No special notes.

    Solicit Synopsis:
  • In “The Other,” Peter Parker returned from the dead and embraced his “inner spider.” But WHAT IF the detente that was reached between man and arachnid had not ended there? What if the man known as Peter Parker had been completely consumed by his inner, bestial impulses, and became more spider than man?

  • No trivia.

See AlsoEdit

  • None.


  1. 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 First and only known appearance to date besides flashbacks

Like this? Let us know!


Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki