FANDOM


  • Apparently Undoniel is having trouble with messages so he asked me to be sure that you're aware characters which appear and/or are mentioned in Hercules and/or Trojan War are canon to Earth-616.

      Loading editor
    • Seems like the message delivery problem is gone, so Jasonmaia:

        Loading editor
    • I thought that the various characters included in the Marvel Classics Comics series should be included in the Ideaverse as they are a direct expression of the various novels where they appear, in fact in every number appears in addition to a pin-up of the author even a short biography of the same. Moreover this would justify the various discrepancies between the same characters described in different series, such as the Bram Stoker's Dracula of Marvel Classics Comics Vol 1 9 and the Dracula and the various supporting characters that appear in the various series of Dracula in the Earth-616 (Tomb of Dracula and above all Dracula Live, where the same novel is described but in a different way). Anyway, I will temporarily suspend the update of the Marvel Classics Comics series (even though I now only have 9 numbers left) waiting for your confirmation, otherwise I will correct the numbers already edited by me, perhaps inserting the "Earth" that seems more congenial to you. The same goes for the ten series of Marvel Illustrated.

      As for The Trojan War, you were absolutely right as I had confused it with Marvel Illustrated: The Iliad Vol 1 and in fact I tried to fix it.

      Always open to further suggestions and corrections, I thank you in advance.

        Loading editor
    • Jasonmaia wrote: I thought that the various characters included in the Marvel Classics Comics series should be included in the Ideaverse as they are a direct expression of the various novels where they appear

      My only counter-example would be Trojan War Vol 1 which is a recollection of various Greek and Roman writings (but I don't think there was any original Marvel material).

      Jasonmaia wrote: in fact in every number appears in addition to a pin-up of the author even a short biography of the same.

      I don't see how it is an argument here. Conan's magazines and handbooks includes a lot of stuff about the authors, yet it is still (without mentioning legal status) in Earth-616.

      Jasonmaia wrote: Moreover this would justify the various discrepancies between the same characters described in different series, such as the Bram Stoker's Dracula of Marvel Classics Comics Vol 1 9 and the Dracula and the various supporting characters that appear in the various series of Dracula in the Earth-616 (Tomb of Dracula and above all Dracula Live, where the same novel is described but in a different way).

      It could indeed justify inconsistencies, but inconsistencies are frequent.

      Jasonmaia wrote: Anyway, I will temporarily suspend the update of the Marvel Classics Comics series (even though I now only have 9 numbers left) waiting for your confirmation, otherwise I will correct the numbers already edited by me, perhaps inserting the "Earth" that seems more congenial to you. The same goes for the ten series of Marvel Illustrated.

      Part or all of those series could indeed be in Ideaverse (like the Haunt of Horror Edgar Poe or even Lovecraft). But what we need is to complete the Ideaverse first, what goes in or out, etc.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message