Amy is a local of Point Pleasant, Ohio. She was the daughter of the county's sheriff. Amy was friends with Ulysses Cain since grade school and had become each other's confidante.
Together they made a pact, that if anything happened to any of them, the other had to get rid of anything embarrassing. Following Ulysses' disappearance, when he had been revealed to be an Inhuman and was secretly taken in by New Attilan, Amy fulfilled the pact and went to his house in order to retrieve a box he kept under his bed.
Some time later, P.I. Jessica Jones was investigating Ulysses for Tony Stark and she was eventually directed to Amy by her dad. Jones and Amy's dad visited her in job at the Frosty Town ice cream shop, and Amy showed Jessica the box, which turned out to contain nothing more than some adult magazines, spare change, drugs and miscellaneous mementos.