- —From the splash page of "The Tough Guy"
Appearing in "The Tough Guy"
Featured Characters:
- Hank Klopp (First appearance; dies)
Supporting Characters:
- Dolly Simms
Antagonists:
- Baldy Jones
Other Characters:
- Ed (Hospital Doctor)
- Doctor (Unnamed)
- Hospital Security Guard (Unnamed)
Races and Species:
Locations:
- Earth
- Baldy Jones' Gym (Unnamed)
- Hospital (Unnamed)
Items:
- Strength Serum
Synopsis for "The Tough Guy"
A muscleman gets pistol whipped and winds up in the hospital. He overhears a conversation between two doctors about a serum that toughens the body so he decides to take it and turn to crime with his powerful body. After he collapses the doctors inform him he has a throat infection that will kill him shortly now that his body is too powerful for medicine to take effect.
Appearing in "Indoor Sport!"
Featured Characters:
- Mona Rand (Ghost, soul or spirit)
Supporting Characters:
- Danny Boland (First appearance; dies)
Other Characters:
- Jim Darvis (Mentioned) (Death)
- Tom
- Dr. Ferris
Races and Species:
Locations:
- Earth
- Country Club (Unnamed)
- Cemetery (Unnamed)
Synopsis for "Indoor Sport!"
A female ghost acquires pictures of men from potential suitors and throws darts into them to inflict pain and death upon the men in revenge for a man who once jilted her.
Appearing in "Willie Brown Is Out To Get Me!"
Featured Characters:
- Monk
Supporting Characters:
- "Weasel"
Antagonists:
- Willie Brown
Other Characters:
- Woman (Unnamed)
Races and Species:
Locations:
Synopsis for "Willie Brown Is Out To Get Me!"
People tell a thug that Willie Brown is after him, which terrifies him, since he shot Willie Brown a week ago and he is now a zombie.
Appearing in "Time Reversal"
- Appearances not yet listed
Synopsis for "Time Reversal"
- Synopsis not yet written
Appearing in "He Who Hesitates..."
Featured Characters:
- Professor William Baker (First appearance; dies)
Supporting Characters:
- Amy Baker
Antagonists:
- Eric Orson
Other Characters:
- Tom
- Dean Edmunds
- Blaines' (Behind the scenes)
- Herrick (Behind the scenes)
- Vice President of Alumni Association (Behind the scenes)
Races and Species:
Locations:
- Earth
- New England
- Deversham
- New England
Synopsis for "He Who Hesitates..."
A hesitant professor finally decides to kill the romeo who's moving in on his wife, but as usual, he waits a little too long and the other man pushes him off the cliff instead so that he can marry the professor's wife.
Appearing in "The Strange Case of Mr. Whimple!"
Featured Characters:
- Henry Simpson (Apparent death)
Antagonists:
- Mr. Whimple
Other Characters:
- Police (Shadow only)
- Mrs. G (Tim's Mother)
- Tim
- Mr. Arbuckle
Races and Species:
Locations:
- Earth
- Boarding House
Synopsis for "The Strange Case of Mr. Whimple!"
A thief attacks a man who always carries a box around on his shoulder with a blackjack and kills him. When he gets the box open, he is startled to see that he has killed one head but not the other and runs into the path of an oncoming train. His intended victim gets up and procures a box for the dead head.
Notes
- The entire issue except for the below story is reprinted in Journey Into Mystery (Vol. 2) #6 with some minor alterations. "He Who Hesitates..." adds text to state Eric Orson was jailed and "Indoor Sport!" adds a twist to story by stating that Tom is also a vengeful spirit except he targets women.
- "Willie Brown Is Out To Get Me!" is reprinted in Fear #22.