Quote1 This one is a revelation! He does not die! Quote2
-- Hybrid src

Early Life

Emery Schaub was employed as a fry cook in Morganton, North Carolina, through unknown means, he gained complete invulnerability and was drafted into the Initiative program, taking the name Boulder.[1]

50-State Initiative

Difficult trainee

He was taken to Camp Hammond, along and in the same squad that Annex, Prodigy (Richard Gilmore), Sunstreak, Gorilla Girl and Batwing. There, he was met with mixed reactions from his fellow new recruits, who found his fan-boyishness somewhat obnoxious. He quickly befriended with Batwing.[1]

He was often looked down upon by the staff, especially Taskmaster who immediately changed his code-name to Butterball at his arrival.[1]

He rubbed Taskmaster the wrong way as while power of total invulnerability was impressive and he was an enthusiastic and dedicated trainee, his lack of physical strength, skill, and wits make him an inappropriate candidate for the superhero program. Much to the frustration of Taskmaster, no amount of training improves Schaub's physical strength and no amount of discipline modifies his behavior or attitude. As a direct consequence of his powers, any kind of punishment was completely ineffectual, and so Taskmaster had the others punished for Butterball's mistakes, pushing them to peer pressure him. At that occasion, his teammates Sunstreak, Prodigy and Annex whipped him with rags, contrary to Batwing who accepted the logic but refused to perform it, and who was amused by the fact Butterball was unharmed and didn't even wake up during the beating attempt. Butterball ended up being slowly isolated from his promotion.[1]

Taskmaster was desperate by that case, but neither Yellowjacket or War Machine accepted to get rid of such power set, the last proposing to use the Kingpin, the Blob and Sumo wrestlers (but Taskmaster answered that those guys had strength Emery lacked), while the former stated that a near-starvation diet might have some effect, after two or three years. Although, Taskmaster refused to admit a failure. He was put on a regime including vegetables and tofu.[1]


Following a press conference where Prodigy un-enthusiastically declared his backing of the Superhuman Registration Act, Annex led his fellow new recruits, Schaub included, on an unauthorized trip off base, using Schaub as a human shield in order to escape while protected from the base security systems.[1]

While the other members of the group went skinny-dipping, Sunstreak made a pass on Schaub. Because Sunstreak's heat generating powers prevent her from close contact with others and Schaub's powers mean he is completely unaffected by heat, an intimate relationship was possible. Schaub, however, due to his inability to physically feel anything anymore as a side effect of his powers, became upset after Sunstreak's advances failed to arouse him. He fled in frustration. On his way back to the base, Schaub was met by the staff members who had gone out after the missing recruits. Much to his teammates' surprise, who were afraid Schaub would squeal on them, Schaub took the entire blame for the incident. He explained his riding on the car hood by claiming he had put a cinderblock on the gas pedal, and had gone to have something else to eat than vegetables and tofu.[1]

Just then, four super-villains, Mr. Hyde, King Cobra, Mauler and Firebrand, attacked in an attempt to kill Taskmaster, but the Initiative won handily when Mauler tried to take Schaub hostage and threatened to kill him, unaware of of his invulnerability, which the instructors demonstrated by firing without concern at him[1] after he unsuccessfully shot Butterball.[2] Mauler's teammates then fled. [1]

Washed out

After the group returned to the base, it was decided that, due to Schaub's inability to increase his strength, he couldn't be taught any effective fighting skills and would have to be washed out of the program. War Machine assured him full Registration privileges, and assured him he had a bright future in many fields of work, including search-and-rescue and hostile environment exploration.[1]

His fate was envied by his promotion colleagues, who wished to be washed out as well, and Batwing asked him to keep contact with them. On his way out, Constrictor and Taskmaster, in a thank-you for his help against the villains and as they understood Emery's pain for leaving Camp Hammond, posed for a picture that made it appear as if Schaub had beaten both of them unconscious. He posted this picture in his room and told his mother that Camp Hammond was the best time of his life.[1]

Shadow Initiative (Earth-616)

Enthusiastic Butterball

Shadow Initiative

After Norman Osborn took control of the Initiative and relocated it to Camp H.A.M.M.E.R., a former Hulkbuster Base in New Mexico, Schaub was recruited into the Shadow Initiative. In the meantime, he hadn't lost his fanboy habits, and asked an autograph from the Ringer.[3]

The Taking of 42

The Shadow Initiative, now a team of expandable superhumans, was sent to Prison 42 in the Negative Zone to fight Blastaar and his forces in order to take back the prison. They were promised by Taskmaster to be soon joined by the "big guns", but were in fact sent first to soft Blastaar's army for the valuable elements to be safe.[4]

Schaub was safe from any harm but disoriented, traumatized after the deaths of Firearms, Slaughter Boy and Johnny Guitar. He was used as a diversion for his teammates to survive.

He contacted Taskmaster for reinforcements, and consequently understood the role of cannon fodder they had. With the assistance of Hardball, an inmate, and the arrival of the promised big guns (Penance, Constrictor, Living Laser, Scorcher...), the facility was retaken.[4]

Avengers The Initiative Vol 1 28 Textless

Propaganda figure


Butterball was subsequently used as a propaganda figure, and surprisingly received lot of support from middle America people, to what Osborn stated that it was because he was "fat and stupid, just like them".[5]

During the attack of the Avengers Resistance on Camp H.A.M.M.E.R. in order to free Night Trasher, Butterball was unable to wake up and take his post.[6]


As most of the H.A.M.M.E.R. and Initiative were heading at Asgard, Oklahoma, the Avengers Resistance attacked Camp H.A.M.M.E.R., all of the Stark's Initiative members were confined to quarters by the Hood.[7] As Penance freed himself, smashing his cell and the noise was heard by Butterball, Batwing and Bengal who left their quarters. This last wanted to take a role in the action, but Butterball was intending to stick to the guards' instructions, until Penance showed up, convincing him to join Avengers Resistance fight against the Norn Stone-powered Shadow Initiative. They made explode the building, and presented their resignation to the Hood before joining the brawl. Butterball himself battled Badd Axe, helping Tigra. As Loki took back control of the stone's power to power Thor's allies, the Avengers Resistance was able to easily defeat the troops of Camp H.A.M.M.E.R.[8]

Heroic Age

Norman Osborn was defeated, the Superhuman Registration Act repealed, and Butterball and Batwing went to the former's hometown, Morganton, and created their own team in order to replace the disgraced and incarcerated U-Foes in the role of North Carolina protectors.[9]

During that period, they were the only initial members,[2] and members of that team.[9]

In his files, Steve Rogers repeated War Machine's statement about Butterball having maybe a role in search-and-rescue and hazardous environment exploration. Even he didn't thought for him to be put in active duty into the Avengers, but still considered him to be a potential asset for specific missions.[10]

A dance was set in the Infinite Avengers Mansion for the Avengers Academy students, and other teen or young adult heroes were invited, including the Young Allies and some former members of the Initiative, and Butterball enjoyed himself on the dance-floor with Hazmat. When Veil informed her that Butterball was invulnerable and so unexpected to be harmed by her radiations, which caused the former to be upset about the fact that the people immune to her powers weren't good-looking, causing an argument with Mettle and leading them to a relationship. Emery seemed to particularly enjoy the party, who ended with a battle between Hardball and Speedball's telekinetic bubbles.[11]

50-State Initiative (Earth-616) from Fear Itself Youth in Revolt Vol 1 1 0001

Assisting to Washington D.C. Prodigy speech

Fear Itself

About one week later,[12] when magical hammers crashed to Earth, Commander Steve Rogers asked Butterball's former teammate Prodigy to gather heroes on a volunteer basis, to help keep the peace by leading a new Initiative without forced conscription or registration. He gathered the heroes for a meeting at Washington D.C., among them Butterball and Batwing.[12]

Soon afterward, he was on the field, dealing with riots and being thrown projectiles at him.[12]

He was among the heroes dispatched at Las Vegas to deal with the impact of earthquakes caused by a brawl between Hardball and Gravity, but was seemingly disoriented, standing still and stating he had always wanted to go to Vegas while the other heroes were struggling with the quakes and trying to save themselves, their teammates or the civilians.[13] When the Heavy Hitters Hotel and Casino fell, he was buried alive under it, and found a few days later in the ruins, safe but seemingly shocked.[14]

Avengers Academy (Earth-616) from Avengers Academy Vol 1 20 0001

Arriving on the new campus

Avengers Academy

In the aftermaths of that crisis, Butterball was, along with Batwing and many other heroes, recruited by Jocasta into the Avengers Academy who was relocated to the Avengers Compound, former headquarters of the West Coast Avenger.[15] Butterball was seemingly part of the part-time students.[16]

Along with his teammates, he was present to witness Jocasta's body after she was seemingly "murdered",[16] and was here to witness as well the arrival of Magneto and the X-Men who came to help to solve the crime.[17]

He seemed to have a great time at the Avengers Academy,[16][18] hanging out with other students.[19]

After the arrival of Hybrid at the Compound, he proposed to play to the new "Crystar, the Crystal Warrior" video game to Reptil who was possessed by his older self and was helping Hybrid in his evil plans so the timeline and the future don't change so his daughter be born. He consequently oriented Butterball to Hybrid, telling him he was a big fan of that video game, for him to capture and fed on Butterball. Hybrid was thrilled by the potential of Emery, whom he stated to be immortal and that he could feed off him forever.[18] When Hybrid was forced to attack the Academy, Butterball was one of the Avengers who kept floating around for him to feed and not of those mind-controlled to battle their teammates, until a magical backlash of White Tiger's amulet allowed him and the other to free from Hybrid's control and to join the fight against him.[20]

Instants later, the campus was visited by Jeremy Briggs and the Briggs Foundation heroes, intending to shut down the Academy. At Briggs' proposal, Butterball refused, astonished that some people with hero potential might prefer be and act as normal persons.[21]

Avengers vs. X-Men

After the Phoenix-powered Emma Frost came to the Avengers Compound to destroy Juston's Sentinel, Giant-Man and Tigra decided to shut down the Avengers Academy for the duration of the Avengers vs. X-Men conflict, and gave a speech whom Butterball assisted.[22]

He rejoined the Academy at some time after it reopened.[23]

Helping the Young Avengers

In order to battle Mother, Prodigy (David Alleyne) called for Transonic and Alex Power, this last calling for more reinforcements, including Cloud 9 who contacted Butterball.[24]

He battled among the "Thin Spandex Line" in Central Park, against hordes of alternate Young Avengers.[25] It is unknown if he attended to the after/New Year party.[26]


Immutability/Invulnerability/Immortality: Butterball is invulnerable to numerous forms of physical harm; being shot at, blown up, burned, drowned, electrocuted, etc, along with psychic attacks, letting the affects of others powers be nullified against him. He once withstood being whipped with rags by Annex, Prodigy (Richard Gilmore) and Sunstreak while sleeping, without even waking up.[1] It was stated that he was also immune to Hazmat's radiations,[11] though it wasn't demonstrated. If a weakness exist, it still hasn't been found.[10]

It was also speculated by the future Reptil that Emery would live forever and never get old. Hybrid confirmed that statement, stating that he "does not die! I can feed off him forever".[18]

That invulnerability come with a few other powers and characteristics:

  • Superhuman Stamina/Modified Metabolism Due to a metabolism different from normal human's, he is stuck in his shape, and doesn't get tired of performing actions available to him: For example, he can run all day without breaking a sweat, albeit slowly. He cannot either getting drunk. It was speculated that a near-starvation regime could made him lose weight after a couple of years,[1] but Hybrid stated while controlling him that he could feed off him forever,[18] hinting that Emery is immortal and would seemingly never lose weight. While his strength is minimal his endurance is virtually inexhaustible. While lifting 150 pounds would be impossible, he could easily lift and cary 150, 1 pound objects consecutively without tiring.
  • Selective Telepathic Immunity: Emery was even stated to be protected from being harmed by telepaths, but that they could still control his mind.[1] However, that statement of Yellowjacket was proven part wrong as Hybrid was able to control him but also to cause him "spiritual" pain.[18]
  • Impaired Sense of Touch/Selective Pain Suppression: As he is invulnerable and has an impaired sense of touch, he was though to be insensible to pain, but Hybrid was able to cause him "spiritual" pain.[18] He could although sense lasers and electricity blasts, tickling him.[1]


Encyclopedic knowledge of superhumans.

Strength level

Weak human.


Quote1 He's not strong. He's not fast. And even if he wasn't built like like a tub of pudding...He'd still be a klutz Quote2
  • Impaired Sense of Touch: As a side-effect of his invulnerability, his sense of touch is impaired.[1]
  • Superhuman Stamina/Modified Metabolism/"Frozen" Body: He's also "frozen" at the physical state he was in when his powers were activated, making his body incapable of losing or gaining weight or muscle mass.[1] It was speculated that a near-starvation regime could made him lose weight after a couple of years,[1] but Hybrid stated while controlling him that he could feed off him forever,[18] hinting that Emery is immortal and would seemingly never lose weight.
  • Extreme Clumsiness[1]
  • Emery stated he couldn't swim.[1]
  • Out of shape and highly unathletic.[1][2]


Homemade costume.[2]

  • While he intended to use the code-name Boulder, he was immediately changed to Butterball by Taskmaster,[1] and never changed back since, even responding to that name.[4]
  • Butterball has a cat named Sam.[1]

Discover and Discuss


  1. 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 Avengers: The Initiative #13
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe A-Z Update #3
  3. Avengers: The Initiative #26
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 Avengers: The Initiative #27
  5. Avengers: The Initiative #28
  6. Avengers: The Initiative #29
  7. Avengers: The Initiative #33
  8. Avengers: The Initiative #34
  9. 9.0 9.1 Avengers: The Initiative #35
  10. 10.0 10.1 Heroic Age: Heroes #1
  11. 11.0 11.1 Avengers Academy #13
  12. 12.0 12.1 12.2 Fear Itself: Youth in Revolt #1
  13. Fear Itself: Youth in Revolt #5
  14. Fear Itself: Youth in Revolt #6
  15. Avengers Academy #20
  16. 16.0 16.1 16.2 Avengers Academy #21
  17. Avengers Academy #22
  18. 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6 Avengers Academy #24
  19. Avengers Academy #23
  20. Avengers Academy #25
  21. Avengers Academy #26
  22. Avengers Academy #33
  23. Avengers Arena #13
  24. Young Avengers Vol 2 #11
  25. Young Avengers Vol 2 #13 credits
  26. He wasn't seen neither in Young Avengers Vol 2 #14 or #15
  27. Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe A-Z Update #3
  28. Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe A-Z Update #3

Like this? Let us know!